LETTURE E CONGETTURE

In bivio. Zur Lebenswegentscheidung als Motiv frühhumanistischer Selbstdarstellung bei Geri von Arezzo und Francesco Petrarca .

Bernhard Schirg
Anno di pubblicazione: 2014
Periodico: Studi Medievali
Serie: Terza
Fascicolo: LV-Fasc I-2014
somdn_product_page

Attenzione: per ottenere gratuitamente questo contenuto devi accedere o registrarti

In bivio. Zur Lebenswegentscheidung als Motiv frühhumanistischer Selbstdarstellung bei Geri von Arezzo und Francesco Petrarca .

Bernhard Schirg
Anno di pubblicazione: 2014
Periodico: Studi Medievali
Serie: Terza
Fascicolo: LV-Fasc I-2014
somdn_product_page

Attenzione: per ottenere gratuitamente questo contenuto devi accedere o registrarti

This article offers a close reading of selected letters of Geri d’Arezzo (* ca. 1270, † before 1339). It comprises a comparative approach to Petrarch’s Secretum meum. Its intention is to show how these two authors make use of the bivium-setting (a diverging point on the path of life) as a powerful and versatile means of self-representation.
According to Coluccio Salutati, Geri d’Arezzo was the first 14th century author to collect his letters. For this reason, modern scholars claimed the « reform of the private letter » for Geri, whose letters can be regarded as « the earliest examples of classicizing epistolary prose » (Ronald Witt). Notwithstanding the fact that they display a great formal variety, a selection of these letters – a pair of metric letters and three letters in prose, one of them containing a Dialogus de amore – seems to share the recurrent bivium theme.
In the Dialogus de amore and the metric letters, the choice between the earthly pleasures of love and the chaste love of God constitutes a bivium. In the metric letters it is presented as a conflict of loyalty between a middle-aged protagonist and two rivalling goddesses (Diana / Venus). In the Dialogus de amore it is Amor himself who tries to win over the figura auctoris Gerius. Both the iconography of Amor and his ambiguous character are shown to derive from contemporary concepts as presented by Geri’s correspondent Francesco da Barberino in the commentary on his Documenti d’Amore.
In two other letters in prose, Geri writes to correspondents who themselves can be considered to be in a situation in bivio: a promising student facing the lure of his adolescentia and a friend of Geri’s facing a marriage without children. Here, Geri seems to act as a life-counselor, assessing contingent scenarios with a considerable amount of Latin sententiae. These quotations most probably derive from various collections compiled to this end. At the same time, Geri anticipates criticism by repeatedly stressing the balance between reading experience and life experience, both of which he claims for himself.
It is striking how many of these themes reappear in Petrarch’s dialogue Secretum meum. As in Geri’s Dialogus de amore, a figura auctoris is seen in conflict at the very same bivium constituted by the two different aspects of love. With his hair turning gray and death coming closer, a reorientation regarding the object of Franciscus’ love becomes more and more urgent. Therefore, St. Augustine – his partner in dialogue – accuses Franciscus of hiding behind a bunch of pretentious sententiae piled up in order to show off, instead of changing his life. Nevertheless, both St. Augustine and Franciscus make extensive use of moral sententiae in their debate. In this way, Petrarch shows himself to be capable of supplying classical quotations for the opposing sides of this conflict. At the same time, through the mutual criticism between the speakers of his dialogue Petrarch proves to be aware of the limits inherent to moral sententiae. With the debate itself not leading to any conversion in the end, it is Petrarch as its author who comes off as silent winner. This aspect of self-representation may explain why the bivium theme is so predominant in Geri’s and Petrarch’s writings. Their way of treating an ethical choice may also be considered an antecedent to the motif of Hercules in bivio, which Erwin Panofsky, Raymond Klibansky and Fritz Saxl claimed as crucial for the early renaissance.

Parole chiave: Bernhard Schirg
Serie: Terza
Fascicolo: LV-Fasc I-2014
Riferimento pagine: Da pag. 299 a pag. 340
Editore: Fondazione Centro italiano di studi sull’alto medioevo
ISBN: 978-88-6809-044-9

DOI: 10.57652/

Tipologia: Versione editoriale (versione pubblicata con il layout dell’editore)
Licenza: Tutti i diritti riservati (All rights reserved)
Formato: PDF
Accesso alla risorsa: Previa registrazione
somdn_product_page

Attenzione: per ottenere gratuitamente questo contenuto devi accedere o registrarti

Condividi questa risorsa su:

This article offers a close reading of selected letters of Geri d’Arezzo (* ca. 1270, † before 1339). It comprises a comparative approach to Petrarch’s Secretum meum. Its intention is to show how these two authors make use of the bivium-setting (a diverging point on the path of life) as a powerful and versatile means of self-representation.
According to Coluccio Salutati, Geri d’Arezzo was the first 14th century author to collect his letters. For this reason, modern scholars claimed the « reform of the private letter » for Geri, whose letters can be regarded as « the earliest examples of classicizing epistolary prose » (Ronald Witt). Notwithstanding the fact that they display a great formal variety, a selection of these letters – a pair of metric letters and three letters in prose, one of them containing a Dialogus de amore – seems to share the recurrent bivium theme.
In the Dialogus de amore and the metric letters, the choice between the earthly pleasures of love and the chaste love of God constitutes a bivium. In the metric letters it is presented as a conflict of loyalty between a middle-aged protagonist and two rivalling goddesses (Diana / Venus). In the Dialogus de amore it is Amor himself who tries to win over the figura auctoris Gerius. Both the iconography of Amor and his ambiguous character are shown to derive from contemporary concepts as presented by Geri’s correspondent Francesco da Barberino in the commentary on his Documenti d’Amore.
In two other letters in prose, Geri writes to correspondents who themselves can be considered to be in a situation in bivio: a promising student facing the lure of his adolescentia and a friend of Geri’s facing a marriage without children. Here, Geri seems to act as a life-counselor, assessing contingent scenarios with a considerable amount of Latin sententiae. These quotations most probably derive from various collections compiled to this end. At the same time, Geri anticipates criticism by repeatedly stressing the balance between reading experience and life experience, both of which he claims for himself.
It is striking how many of these themes reappear in Petrarch’s dialogue Secretum meum. As in Geri’s Dialogus de amore, a figura auctoris is seen in conflict at the very same bivium constituted by the two different aspects of love. With his hair turning gray and death coming closer, a reorientation regarding the object of Franciscus’ love becomes more and more urgent. Therefore, St. Augustine – his partner in dialogue – accuses Franciscus of hiding behind a bunch of pretentious sententiae piled up in order to show off, instead of changing his life. Nevertheless, both St. Augustine and Franciscus make extensive use of moral sententiae in their debate. In this way, Petrarch shows himself to be capable of supplying classical quotations for the opposing sides of this conflict. At the same time, through the mutual criticism between the speakers of his dialogue Petrarch proves to be aware of the limits inherent to moral sententiae. With the debate itself not leading to any conversion in the end, it is Petrarch as its author who comes off as silent winner. This aspect of self-representation may explain why the bivium theme is so predominant in Geri’s and Petrarch’s writings. Their way of treating an ethical choice may also be considered an antecedent to the motif of Hercules in bivio, which Erwin Panofsky, Raymond Klibansky and Fritz Saxl claimed as crucial for the early renaissance.

Parole chiave: Bernhard Schirg
Fascicolo: LV-Fasc I-2014
Riferimento pagine: Da pag. 299 a pag. 340
Editore: Fondazione Centro italiano di studi sull’alto medioevo
ISBN: 978-88-6809-044-9

DOI: 10.57652/

Tipologia: Versione editoriale (versione pubblicata con il layout dell’editore)
Licenza: Tutti i diritti riservati (All rights reserved)
Formato: PDF
Accesso alla risorsa: Previa registrazione
somdn_product_page

Attenzione: per ottenere gratuitamente questo contenuto devi accedere o registrarti

Condividi questa risorsa su:

Che cosa significa Cisam Open Access

La Fondazione CISAM apre le porte del suo prezioso archivio scientifico a tutti! In linea con la sua missione storica, il CISAM vuole rendere liberamente accessibili a chiunque le riviste e le monografie che ha raccolto nel corso degli anni. Abbracciando i principi della Dichiarazione di Berlino sull’accesso aperto alla conoscenza, il progetto CisamOA sfrutta il potere del digitale per diffondere a livello globale i risultati delle ricerche, senza alcun ostacolo.

Ti potrebbe interessare anche…
keyboard_arrow_up